What if most of your Shopify store’s profit comes from just a small portion of your products?
This is the idea behind the Pareto Principle, also known as the 80/20 Rule. In ecommerce, it suggests that approximately 80% of business results may come from just 20% of products, customers, or marketing activities.
Although the exact ratio varies between businesses, one thing is clear: not every product contributes equally to your store’s profitability.
Some products consistently generate strong sales and healthy profit margins, while others consume advertising budgets, require frequent discounts, or tie up money in slow-moving inventory.
Understanding which products actually drive your profit can help you make smarter decisions about inventory, pricing, advertising, and product development.
In this guide, you’ll learn what the Pareto Principle means for ecommerce, how to identify your most profitable Shopify products, and how to use the 80/20 Rule to improve your store’s financial performance.
The Pareto Principle is the observation that approximately 80% of outcomes often come from 20% of inputs. It is commonly known as the 80/20 Rule and is associated with Italian economist Vilfredo Pareto.
In ecommerce, the principle suggests that a relatively small portion of a business’s products, customers, or activities may generate a disproportionately large share of its results.
For example:
20% of products may generate 80% of total revenue.
20% of products may contribute 80% of total product profit.
20% of customers may account for a large share of total sales.
20% of marketing campaigns may generate most of a store’s profitable conversions.
These percentages are illustrative rather than guaranteed. A store might follow a 70/30 or 90/10 distribution instead.
The key takeaway is that product performance is rarely distributed equally across an ecommerce catalog.
A Shopify store with 100 products might discover that only 15 products consistently generate strong profits, while the remaining products contribute relatively little.
This makes product-level profitability analysis essential. Instead of treating every product equally, merchants can identify which items deserve more investment and which need further evaluation.
One of the most common mistakes in ecommerce is assuming that the products generating the highest revenue are automatically the most valuable to the business.
However, revenue and profit measure different aspects of financial performance.
Consider a Shopify store selling three products:
| Metric | Product A | Product B | Product C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Units sold | 500 | 200 | 100 |
| Selling price | $50 | $80 | $120 |
| Revenue | $25,000 | $16,000 | $12,000 |
| COGS | $15,000 | $4,800 | $3,600 |
| Other variable costs | $7,000 | $3,200 | $2,400 |
| Contribution profit | $3,000 | $8,000 | $6,000 |
Illustrative figures. Other variable costs include applicable advertising, payment processing, fulfillment, and other selling expenses.
Product A generates the highest revenue and sells the most units. However, Product B generates the highest contribution profit.
Why?
Product A has higher sales volume but also significantly higher costs. Product B retains more profit after accounting for the expenses associated with selling it.
This highlights three important distinctions:
Bestselling product: The product generating the most sales or units sold.
Most profitable product: The product generating the highest total profit after relevant costs.
Highest-margin product: The product retaining the largest percentage of revenue as profit.
These categories are not interchangeable.
For example, a product with a 60% contribution margin might generate less total profit than a product with a 25% margin if the latter sells in much higher quantities.
Merchants should therefore evaluate both total profit and profit margin when identifying their most valuable products.
To understand this further, see our guide to Contribution Margin for Ecommerce: Formula, Example, and How to Calculate It for Shopify.
The 80/20 Rule becomes useful when you apply it to actual product performance data.
Here are four practical steps to identify the products driving your store’s profitability.
Start by gathering financial and sales information for every product in your catalog.
Important metrics include:
Total units sold.
Gross sales and net sales.
Discounts and refunds.
Cost of Goods Sold (COGS).
Advertising expenses.
Payment processing fees.
Fulfillment and shipping costs.
The goal is to understand how much money each product generates and how much it costs to sell it.
For example, a product might appear highly profitable when you only consider its selling price and manufacturing cost. However, after accounting for advertising, payment fees, refunds, and fulfillment, its actual contribution may be considerably lower.
Accurate product-level analysis depends on having complete and consistently recorded cost data.
Once you’ve collected the necessary data, calculate the contribution profit of each product.
A simplified formula is:
Product Contribution Profit = Net Sales − COGS − Variable Selling Costs
Where:
Net Sales account for discounts and refunds.
COGS represents the direct cost of the products sold.
Variable Selling Costs include applicable advertising, transaction fees, fulfillment, and other selling expenses.
For example, imagine a product generates $10,000 in net sales.
| Cost component | Amount |
|---|---|
| Net Sales | $10,000 |
| COGS | $3,000 |
| Advertising costs | $2,000 |
| Payment processing fees | $300 |
| Fulfillment costs | $700 |
| Contribution Profit | $4,000 |
Its contribution profit is:
$10,000 − $3,000 − $2,000 − $300 − $700 = $4,000
Its contribution margin is:
($4,000 ÷ $10,000) × 100 = 40%
This gives merchants a more meaningful understanding of product performance than revenue alone.
Note: Shared advertising and operating expenses may require reasonable allocation methods. Contribution profit is not necessarily the same as fully allocated accounting net profit.
If you want to understand how efficiently your marketing generates revenue, read our guide to Marketing Efficiency Ratio (MER): A Simplified Overview.
After calculating contribution profit, rank your products from highest to lowest.
Consider the following example:
| Product | Contribution Profit | Share of Total Profit |
|---|---|---|
| Product A | $12,000 | 40% |
| Product B | $8,000 | 26.7% |
| Product C | $5,000 | 16.7% |
| Product D | $2,000 | 6.7% |
| Product E | $1,500 | 5% |
| Other products | $1,500 | 5% |
| Total | $30,000 | 100% |
In this example, the top three products generate approximately 83.4% of total contribution profit.
Although they represent only a portion of the product catalog, they contribute the overwhelming majority of its profitability.
This is exactly the type of concentration that the Pareto Principle helps merchants identify.
To understand how concentrated your store’s profitability is, calculate the cumulative percentage of profit generated by your highest-performing products.
The formula is:
Cumulative Profit Contribution = (Cumulative Profit of Ranked Products ÷ Total Product Profit) × 100
For example:
| Product Group | Cumulative Share of Profit |
|---|---|
| Top 10% of products | 40% |
| Top 20% of products | 66.7% |
| Top 30% of products | 83.4% |
This shows how much of your store’s contribution profit comes from its best-performing products.
You may discover that your actual distribution is 70/30, 85/15, or something entirely different from the traditional 80/20 ratio.
The objective is not to force your store into an 80/20 distribution. It is to understand where your profit actually comes from.
Identifying your most profitable products is only the beginning. The real value comes from using that information to make better business decisions.
Here are four strategies Shopify merchants can consider.
If certain products consistently generate strong contribution profit, consider allocating more resources to them.
This could include:
Increasing advertising budgets for campaigns with healthy profitability.
Improving product pages to increase conversion rates.
Creating bundles around popular products.
Maintaining sufficient inventory to avoid stockouts.
Featuring profitable products in email marketing and promotional campaigns.
However, avoid increasing advertising spend based on revenue alone. A product that performs well organically may not maintain the same profitability when acquisition costs increase.
Monitor contribution margin as you scale.
Products that generate little profit deserve closer attention.
Before discontinuing them, investigate why they underperform.
Possible reasons include:
High manufacturing or sourcing costs.
Excessive advertising expenses.
Frequent discounts.
High return or refund rates.
Expensive shipping and fulfillment.
Low selling prices relative to costs.
Sometimes, small adjustments can improve profitability significantly.
For example, increasing the selling price, negotiating supplier costs, improving conversion rates, or reducing unnecessary advertising spend may turn an underperforming product into a more profitable one.
Your most profitable products can also help increase the value of other items in your catalog.
Consider pairing a high-performing product with a complementary item that has lower sales volume.
For example, a skincare store might bundle its best-selling moisturizer with a less popular facial cleanser.
This strategy can:
Increase Average Order Value (AOV).
Introduce customers to additional products.
Improve the sales performance of slower-moving inventory.
Increase total profit per order when bundle pricing is structured carefully.
The key is to evaluate the profitability of the entire bundle, including additional discounts, fulfillment expenses, and product costs.
Learn more about this metric in our guide to Average Order Value (AOV): A Simplified Overview.
There is one potential downside to the Pareto Principle: overdependence.
If a small group of products generates most of your profit, your business could become vulnerable when something goes wrong.
For example:
A supplier increases prices.
A competitor launches a similar product.
A product becomes unavailable.
Advertising costs increase.
Customer demand declines.
Instead of relying entirely on your existing winners, consider developing additional profitable products and diversifying your product portfolio.
Inventory management is also important. Holding too much stock of a product that sells slowly can tie up working capital and increase storage costs.
Monitor inventory performance alongside profitability. Our guide to [Inventory Turnover Ratio] can be linked here once the corresponding GoProfit article is published.
The objective is not simply to maximize the performance of your top 20%. It is also to reduce unnecessary business risk.
Although the 80/20 Rule is useful, merchants should avoid treating it as a universal formula.
Here are five common mistakes to watch out for.
Not every ecommerce business follows the same distribution.
Your top 20% of products might generate 60%, 75%, or even 90% of your total product profit.
Use actual performance data rather than assuming the ratio is always 80/20.
A high-revenue product may have low margins, expensive advertising, or high refund rates.
Always evaluate the costs associated with generating those sales.
A profitable product that frequently goes out of stock represents a missed opportunity.
Monitor inventory turnover and stock levels alongside product profitability to maintain availability without overstocking.
A product might perform exceptionally well during a seasonal promotion but generate much lower profit throughout the rest of the year.
Compare consistent reporting periods and consider seasonal trends before discontinuing products or significantly increasing investment.
Product contribution profit does not automatically equal final business profit.
Shared expenses such as salaries, software subscriptions, rent, and general operating costs may not be included in product-level calculations.
Understand which costs are included before making major business decisions.
details easy to understand before shoppers proceed to checkout.
Understanding which products drive your store’s profitability requires more than looking at your Shopify sales dashboard.
Merchants need to connect revenue with the costs behind each sale to understand which products are actually contributing to business growth.
This is where profit analytics becomes important.
With GoProfit, Shopify merchants can bring sales, product costs, advertising expenses, and other business costs into a more comprehensive profitability view.
Instead of evaluating products based solely on how much they sell, merchants can use profitability insights to investigate:
Which products contribute most to overall profit.
Whether high-revenue products maintain healthy margins.
How advertising expenses affect profitability.
Whether discounts and refunds are reducing financial performance.
Where rising costs may be affecting the bottom line.
By regularly reviewing product performance alongside overall profitability, merchants can make more informed decisions about pricing, marketing budgets, inventory, and product strategy.
The goal is simple: understand not just what sells, but what makes your business money.